Since 1989, efforts to understand the nature of interfirm resource sharing in the form of industrial symbiosis and to replicate in a deliberate way what was largely selforganizing in kalundborg, denmark have followed many paths, some with much success and some with very little. Organizational boundary change in industrial symbiosis. Industrial symbiosis is is a concept based on the idea of industrial ecosystems, establishing symbiotic relationships between economically independent industries, typically in a relatively close geographical proximity chertow, 2000. Industrial symbiosis has proven to be an important tool for improving. Uncovering industrial symbiosis chertow 2007 journal of. It is suggested that, as soon as an industrial area is. An industrial ecosystem refers to the idea of reusing waste from one industrial process in another industrial process. Uncovering industrial symbiosis chertow 2007 journal.
The creation of such innovative partnerships within a territory leads to the development of an industrial symbiosis. Examining industrial symbiosis in practice for this section involved three primary activities. Industrial ecology is a relatively new field that is based on a natural paradigm, claiming that an industrial ecosystem may behave in a similar way to the natural ecosystem wherein everything gets recycled, albeit the simplicity and. An industrial ecosystem refers to the idea of reusing. Written by two members of the research and development staff at general motors, this article laid out the conceptual. Pdf the industrial symbiosis research symposium at yale. The industrial symbiosis research symposium at yale. The part of industrial ecology known as industrial symbiosis engages traditionally separate industries2 in a collective approach to competitive advantage involving physical exchangeofmaterials,energy,waterandbyproducts. Removing the intentionality from this definition, industrial symbiosis concerns the material and energy flows and transformations that are generated by economic actors within a geographically bound system. Special issue diverse dynamics of industrial symbiosis. Industrial ecology in developing countries center for. According to chertow et al,5 there are three primary opportunities for. It describes how a network of diverse organizations can foster ecoinnovation and longterm culture change, create and share mutually profitable transactions and improve business and technical processes.
Introduction an early analysis of industrial symbiosis is in the scientific literature presented the analogy between humanmade manufacturing systems that cooperate on the exchange of resources to a mutually beneficial end and cyclic organization patterns found in biological systems hardy and graedel, 2002. Based on the research gaps that we identify, we provide suggestions to guide the future development. Current status, emerging challenges, and future prospects. Pdf scholarship and practice in industrial symbiosis. Industrial symbiotic relations as cooperative games. Industrial ecology and business model evolution 2 and firm competitiveness by enhancing resource productivity and closing material loops. The keys to industrial symbiosis are collaboration and the synergistic possibilities offered by geographic proximity. Industrial symbiosis falls within the field of industrial ecology. Industrial ecology arose in the 1990s as a new discipline that places emphasis on the sustainability of energy and material flows. Marian chertow, weslynne ashton, and radha kuppalli. Industrial symbiosis and waste recovery in an indian. The part of industrial ecology known as industrial symbiosis engages traditionally separate industries in a collective. Industrial symbiosis as a regional development tool 67 dr. We welcome your announcements, call for papers and announcements of academic publications.
Structure and morphology of industrial symbiosis networks. In july of 2019, the 16 th annual industrial symbiosis research symposium isrs will be held on the friday and saturday 5 th6 th before the 2019 international society of industrial ecology conference. Pdf abstract industrial symbiosis, as part of the emerging field of industrial ecology, demands resolute attention. Abstract industrial symbiosis, a subfield of industrial ecology, engages tradition ally separate industries and entities in a. Absorptive capacity and industrial symbiosis experiences. Industrial symbiosis engages traditionally separate industries in a collective approach to competitive advantage involving physical exchanges of materials, energy, water andor byproducts. Industrial symbiosis, a subfield of industrial ecology, examines the flow of water, energy, materials, and byproducts across firms in geographic proximity. Industrial innovation analysis and evaluation towards. Dear colleagues, this special issue seeks to deepen knowledge of industrial symbiosis, a prominent concept in industrial ecology focusing on networks of firms that share physical resources including water, energy, and byproduct materials. Development of sustainable performance measurement. Special feature on industrial symbiosis uncovering industrial symbiosis marian r. Rachel lombardi school of engineering, university of birmingham, uk. View the article pdf and any associated supplements and figures for a period of 48 hours.
Ehrenfeld and gertler, 1997, chertow, 2007, lombardi and laybourn, 2012. Industrial symbiosis wikimili, the best wikipedia reader. Marian chertow is a professor of industrial environmental management at the yale school of forestry and environmental studies and director of the center for industrial ecology. While there are numerous antecedents to industrial ecology as erkman and others have well demonstrated, many agree that modern industrial ecology was greatly inspired by, or even began with, the seminal 1989 article in scientific american, strategies for manufacturing.
Industrial symbiosis can be considered as a critical factor in the sustainability of industrial regions because it promotes a collective approach to reduce environmental damage with both private and public benefits. Reviewing industrial symbiosis literature, we encounter recent contributions focused on different aspects of this concept. Velenturf, apm and jensen, pd 2016 promoting industrial symbiosis. Recent citations lin shi requirements engineering for an industrial symbiosis tool for industrial parks.
Implementing the concept of industrial symbiosis at industrial parks will turn them into eco industrial parks. There are three primary opportunities for resource exchange. Kalundborg, literally share ground water, surface water and waste water, steam and electricity, and also exchange a variety of residues that become feedstocks in other processes see figure 2. Industrial symbiosis the concept of industrial symbiosis, according chertow, et al. To work with international colleagues to adapt industrial ecology theory and practice to the realities faced in industrializing countries related to comingled problems of energy access, water quality and quantity, waste and material management, and global warming and to gather and. While these provide necessary insight into stages of industrial symbiosis development, additional empirical study is needed, especially to understand the evolution of. Revisiting the guitang group in china lin shi and marian chertow school of forestry and environmental studies, yale university, 195 prospect st, new haven, ct 06511, usa. In 3, they present the concept of perfect industrial symbiosis and verify the quality of any given isr by measuring its distance to such a perfect form. An industrial symbiosis constitutes a local partnership where, partners provide, share and reuse resources to create shared value. Industrial symbiosis is a subset of industrial ecology, with a particular focus on material and energy exchange. Moreover will implementing industrial symbiosis result in a collective benefit for the involved companies that will be greater than the sum of the benefits if the companies would have operated by themselves chertow 2000.
Industrial symbiosis potential and urban infrastructure capacity in mysuru, india to cite this article. Industrial symbiosis is concerned with closing materials cycles by using wastes from one facility as an alternative input for another facility. Industrial symbiosis henceforward is may be understood as the mutually advantageous utilization of residues and byproducts between traditionally separate industrial entities m. The kalundborg eips are the first example of industrial symbiosis 15, and many others are followed in other countries such as australia, the netherlands, etc. They generally have both economic and environmental benefits. Industrial symbiosis is the iconic application of industrial ecology e. Marian ruth chertow is an american academic specializing in environmental management she holds a b. Industrial symbiosis ecoindustrial development section update novemberdecember, 2012 peter lowitt, faicp this update service is provided by the industrial symbiosis ecoindustrial development section of the international society for industrial ecology. An ontology of industrial symbiosis the design of a support tool for collaborative industrial symbiosis research with as test cases from tianjin economic development area and kalundborg master thesis engineering and policy analysis author sebastiaan nooij 1236016 s. Using the concept of proximity to explore social network development. Industrial symbiosis is the name of the subsection of the broader field of industrial ecology that pays careful attention to networked resource exchanges. Summary since 1989, efforts to understand the nature of interfirm resource sharing in the form of industrial symbiosis and to replicate in a.
Life cycle energy and environmental benefits of a us. The kalundborg symbiosis exemplifies the idea that through collaboration it is possible to find common solutions to specific problems. Proposal for a comparative framework f boons, m chertow, j park, w spekkink, h shi journal of industrial ecology 21 4, 938952, 2017. While these provide necessary insight into stages of industrial symbiosis development, additional empirical study is needed, especially to understand the evolution of facilitated industrial symbiosis.
Industrial symbiosis is a collaborative approach concerning physical. Director, industrial environmental management program, yale school of forestry. Supply chain collaboration in industrial symbiosis. Industrial symbiosis last updated february 27, 2020. Industrial synergies are forms of collaborative partnerships between companies resulting in the sharing of resources or the exchange of material or energy byproducts.
The industrial symbiosis approach pure research information. Jun 16, 2014 the theory, methodologies, and case studies in the field of industrial symbiosis have been developing for nearly 30 years. Supply chain collaboration in industrial symbiosis networks. Special feature on industrial symbiosis industrial. Chertow summary since 1989, efforts to understand the nature of inter. Industrial symbiosis is represents that two or more industrial operations, which are preferably close to each other physically and work independently, form longterm partnerships and work in solidarity to increase resource efficiency, environmental performance and competitiveness. A comprehensive definition of industrial symbiosis is that offered by chertow 2004. Industrial symbiosis a subset of industrial ecology. Malcolm bailey, nispyorkshire humber, uk session 3b discussion and research questions 69 session 4.
Industrial symbiosis is a business collaboration where residuals from one enterprise serve as input for another enterprise thereby improving bottomline figures and competiveness for the business partners and reducing the total impact of the industry on the. Other experiences of industrial symbiosis emerged between one mostly industrial cluster and the other companies that use similar resources and generate similar products 15. This paper deals with is networks formed by economic actors within a broader region. Industrial symbiosis dynamics and the problem of equivalence.
Models of industrial symbiosis according to the formation mechanism, we can distinguish between two stylized models of industrial symbiosis chertow 2007. Industrial symbiosis potential and urban infrastructure. This is a pdf file of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for publication. Industrial symbiosis has also been defined as an inclusive descriptor for the myriad ways industrial outputs are. It describes how a network of diverse organizations can foster ecoinnovation and longterm culture change, create. Ecoindustrial parks development and integrated management. Complex networks of symbiotic industries, also known as industrial ecosystems, are thought to exist in many industrial regions, but may not yet be.
Industrial symbiosis research symposium 2019 powered by. In turkey, the is approach is being realized within the scope. An industrial symbiosis is a physical exchange of materials, energy, water, and byproducts among diversified clusters of firms marian chertow, yale university. Uncovering industrial symbiosis by marian chertow ssrn. Industrial symbiosis, dynamic capabilities, organizational learning, absorptive capacity, sme research question, hypothesis and relevance. Industrial symbiosis and residual recovery in the nanjangud. To download a free pdf of the report or to order printed copies. This twoday event will begin with one day of symbiosis study tours and networking at the beijing. Industrial symbiosis engages traditionally separate industries in a collective approach to competitive advantage, involving the physical exchange of materials, energy, water, or byproducts. Regarding industrial symbiosis tools, chertow 5 has defined several useful tools in industrial symbiosis analysis like industrial inventories, inputoutput matching, stakeholder processes, and material budgeting. In 2012, chertow and ehrenfeld 2012 introduced five new development options for is, such as built and recruit model, planned ecoindustrial park model peip, selforganising symbiosis model sos, retrofit industrial park model rip and the circular economy ecoindustrial park model ceeip. The yale program on industrial ecology in developing countries was launched in 2007, with the following mission. She is also appointed at the yale school of management and the national university of singapore.
Her research and teaching focus on industrial ecology, businessenvironment issues, circular economy, waste. Industrial symbiosis ecoindustrial development section update. Journal of industrial ecology 111, 2007 6 chertow, m. Agentbased model of selforganized industrial symbiosis. Regional synergy developments in kwinana, western australia kwinana industrial area western australia is the largest and most sparsely populated state in australia. Since 1989, efforts to understand the nature of interfirm resource sharing in the form of industrial symbiosis and to replicate in a deliberate way what was largely self. Advancing the study of industry and environment marian chertow, weslynne ashton, and radha kuppalli abstract industrial symbiosis is, a subfield of industrial ecology, is principally concerned with the cooperative management of resource flows through networks of businesses as a. Industrial symbiosis, a subfield of industrial ecology, engages traditionally separate industries and entities in a collaborative approach to resource sharing that benefits both the environment. The application of industrial ecology and ecoindustry networks remains in an early stage. Theory and case studies chertow is associate professor of industrial environmental management. Uncovering industrial symbiosis center for industrial ecology.
1018 382 391 762 1245 726 900 589 1452 107 240 974 1152 927 206 1509 690 1187 911 501 1246 694 246 1234 1371 164 55 1000 578 718